Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Combo Pie
Garlic Chicken Pie
Cheese Pizza
Gluten Free Cheese Pizza
About
Carmine's
At Carmine's, you can expect a wide array of delicious pizzas, from classic cheese to specialty pies like the Combo Pie with bacon, pepperoni, sausage, and more. The Garlic Chicken Pie is a must-try with its white sauce base and flavorful toppings. For those looking for lighter options, the Garden Salad and Greek Salad are fresh and satisfying choices.
Customers rave about the quality and taste of the pizzas at Carmine's. One reviewer even compared it to the best pizza in New Haven, Ct. The friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere make dining here a truly enjoyable experience.
Whether you're stopping in for a quick bite or hosting a large group, Carmine's has something for everyone. With options for takeout, delivery, and reservations, it's easy to enjoy their delicious food.
Be sure to visit Carmine's on Main St and experience the best pizza in Chatham for yourself. You won't be disappointed!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ I want to give more than 5 stars to this place. They could not have been friendlier and more welcoming to our large group after a soccer tournament nearby. We coordinated a drop in dinner by phone earlier in the week, during a time when all the nearby restaurants were mobbed, Carmines went out of the way to make it work for us. Really great experience. Kids gobbled up the food. ”
“ The Pizza is to die for! Quality, large pizza, lots of toppings, cheese and sauce!!! Best Pizza this side of New Haven, Ct.- Pete's. The crust is crunchy & yet chewy. The red sause is wonderful & they don't skimp on it!!! The cheese is high quality. It somehow reminds me of a great pizza in Italy or Europe!!! The folks there are super friendly & nice too. We talked about our gardens and food while I was waiting. Far and way the very best. ”
“ Good pizza by any measure. Generous ingredients, good crust, real cheese. On busy nights I would definitely order ahead. ”
“ Stopped in for a quick bite and was surprised at how great this place is. Pizza by the slice was delicious and hot. I had both of the special slices and they were delicious. My adult daughter had plain cheese and very much enjoyed that! We had a coffee and dessert afterwards as we walked around the town. Both were delicious! Highly recommend for a quick and delicious bite while enjoying the town. ”
“ Carmine's came recommended as the best pizza in Chatham and did not disappoint. Great pizza and great people. ”
“ Carmine's has the best pizza and the nicest workers. We came in shortly before closing and they made us custom pizzas and allowed us to stay and eat after normal hours. The owner and the entire staff were very accommodating to our food allergies and let us know the exact ingredients in all of their food. Would highly recommend for anyone looking for a great pizza in the cape! ”
“ The pizza was really good here! Not as crispy as Palio Pizza in Hyannis (see my review on how that was like eating a tortilla chip), but it did have very flavorful sauce and melty cheese. The greek side salad was a little bit sad and pricey but the dressing was good. All in all, not a bad choice for a slice of pizza! Service was very friendly and it has tables both inside and out. ”
“ The pizza here was decent. The cheese pizza had a spicy marinara sauce and the veggie pizza was loaded. The crust was a bit on the tougher side but we did have to drive 30 min before we could eat the pizza so that probably made a difference. The large pizza is a decent size that can easily feed 3-4 people. ”
“ Ordered takeout here on 4th of July - This town is slammed that week. They were really backed up and they did a great job catching up and getting the pizza done in a decent time. The pizza was excellent. It's a small place that has a few tables, but does mostly takeout. ”
